I'm surprised to read this!
I guess my question would be the exact same!! I was trying to find a good Mumford and Sons song to play as our first dance.
With the new album out, I thought maybe Ghost That We Knew might be nice...but i'm not sure if it sounds more dark than happy.
My fiance' was NEVER into this type of music, and when we took our first road trip together I put it on and he looked at me funny and said "you like this? what's with the banjo??" Then we listened to the rest of the Sigh No More album and by the end of it he said "oh...this isn't too bad"
A year and a half later HE has the Sigh No More album and had Babel pre-ordered. We listened to the entire album together for the first time on our way up to the cottage. That same weekend he proposed to me at sunset and when we went back into the car, I had Mumford playing in the background
It just seems perfect to have them playing as our first song.